Don't forget to visit The Waldorf Review for more up-to-date school reviews and news stories.
Showing posts with label tuscon waldorf school. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tuscon waldorf school. Show all posts

Thursday, May 3, 2012

Camphill Special School - Review by a Teacher



http://www.greatschools.org/pennsylvania/glenmoore/3998-Camphill-Special-Schools\
/


Posted on Oct 8, 2011
Report it

Although I agree that this school fosters a strong sense of community and
student wellness and possesses teachers that are truly dedicated to their
students, I would have to disagree that this school is nonsectarian. If you
research Rudolph Steiner, who developed anthroposophy, and thus the Waldorf
curriculum, he was an esoteric occultist. The teaching that infuses this school
are based on anthroposophic ideals, which is part of the larger New Age
movement. For example, the teachers follow the students through each grade
because they are considered to be the child's spiritual guide as they continue
on the path of reincarnation. Legends, fairytales, and myths are no longer just
symbols and allegory, but realities that are avenues for "spiritual
advancement." Please, before enrolling your child in this school, if you belong
to any religious denomination, particularly a Christian denomination, research
Rudolph Steiner and what the Waldorf curriculum really is and then make an
educated choice. --Submitted by a teacher

Sunday, April 29, 2012

Davis Waldorf School Reviews - by Parents


http://www.greatschools.org/school/parentReviews.page?id=9658&state=CA#from..Hea\
derLink


8/9/2011
After leaving this school and having my kids tested, I would never go back
again. You think your paying to give your kids a head start while passing on the
love of learning, come to find out 6 years latter your really crippling them in
"this" program. (Test scores showed, child three years behind due to lack of
instruction. When child was instructed the scores jumped two grade levels in a 6
month period.)
Davis has incredible public schools, that help children excel academically and
have a lot of the same feel as this place, once did.
Check out one great school, Patwin.

Posted August 2, 2011
Our child spent four years at this school. After a few positive experiences in
the beginning, we had a miserable time at this school. Our child was bullied,
subjected to hate speech, beaten by a bully while being held by the bully's
sidekick. The teacher had zero previous teaching experience, pigeon-holed
children and treated all according to what she thought she "knew" about them as
though she had some special psychological insight into their karma. The teacher
was a disaster on the level of personal interaction and in terms of academics.
The principal is in a position of doling out financial favors to members of the
school board and therefore, rules supreme without any meaningful supervision,
and acts arbitrarily. Extremely hurtful environment and academically a disaster.
—Submitted by a parent

Posted February 5, 2011
Horrible experience. My son came from a very bad experience in the Davis School
system and transferred to Davis Waldorf in November. He said goodbye to his
teacher in June and in July we received a termination letter about his
enrollment. We did not receive any contact prior to this letter. I contacted the
office but they did not respond at all. My son has now been diagnosed with high
functioning autism and could have used the support of this school but they
dropped him as fast as they could after taking our tuition money.
—Submitted by a parent


Wow! It looks like the sudden attention to the Waldorf school reviews is
prompting parents to make their voices heard. This review appeared on the Davis
Waldorf School board within the last few minutes:

http://www.greatschools.org/school/parentReviews.page?id=9658&state=CA#from..Hea\
derLink


Posted today
Davis Waldorf has been a true disappointment. After a few years it has become
clear that it is not simply a school with an emphasis on the Arts. Though almost
never mentioned the school is founded on the philosophy of one Rudolf Steiner
(labelled an educator but had no credentials), called Anthroposophy. This theory
is almost never mentioned but forms the basis for everything which goes on at
the school. Anthroposophy is an esoteric philosophy which incorporates karma,
racial hierarchies, categorizing children into the four temperaments, and plenty
of other Anthro nonsense. Children are encouraged to look back into antiquity
rather than modern knowledge for answers. They are taught the ancient 4 element
theory is fact, that myths and stories are fact. They are not taught to read
until at least 7 years old. Parents are told this is to avoid rushing education.
The reality is that Anthroposophy teaches that a child does not incarnate into
their Astral body until adult teeth form, this happens around the age of 7, that
only once the Astral body has fully incarnated can any intellectual faculty be
exercised. This education is not right for my children. Do you feel it's right
for yours? —Submitted by a parent

WE'RE LISTENING! Is WALDORF?

Tucson Waldorf School Reviews - by Parents


http://www.greatschools.org/school/parentReviews.page?id=3161&state=AZ&sortBy=dd\
&page=3#revPagination


Posted October 12, 2011
Many children thrive here, but beware, this school can be extremely damaging for
some children and it took us almost a year to build our child s confidence back
up after he attended. The school is beautiful and lively and full of amazing
smells, music, and art and we did appreciate the holistic curriculum. However,
there is absolutely nothing scientific about the guiding principles of the
school, as one parent remarked, but rather the philosophical principals and
spiritual path developed by Rudolph Steiner (Anthroposophy), which is very
radical. Beware that children are placed into one of Steiners four categories by
temperament early on and teachers base their interactions and attitudes with
children on these temperaments, which are utterly arbitrary and completely lack
social and cultural context. This was extremely damaging for our child, because
our child did not fit perfectly in one of the boxes. If only he was slender,
elegant, and well-balanced instead of big and fleshy he would have received the
proper stimulation and attitude from the staff- -which is a ridiculous basis for
interaction between teacher and student.
—Submitted by a parent

Posted May 31, 2011
Wasn't the school for us at all and so we had a terrible and traumatic year. My
child's teacher was not adept at working with all types of children. Some
children appear to excell, but others are judged constantly. There very very few
days that I wasnt reminded how to parent better. Be sure to really look into the
ideology of this school because it apparently did not align with ours. Not a
pleasant experience at all. —Submitted by a parent

Posted March 14, 2011
Based on Steiner's philosophy of education, known as anthroposophy, it divides
education into developmental stages similar to Piaget's stages of child
development. This school initially seemed like a dream...the curriculum and
teachers view education as holistic and organic and emphasizes a balance of
developing the child not only intellectually, but emotionally, and artistically.
However, much like Steiner himself...we found this school to be extremely
elitist with absolutely no room for conflicting ideas of lifestyle, culture, or
ideologies. As immigrants from a non-white country, we found the parents and
educators to be more concerned with sugar, gluten, television, and artificial
colors then education. In other words, completely out of touch with reality. I
also agree with the parent that many teachers are brilliant, however lack the
ability to understand children that are not perfectly "Waldorf". I found this
school to do the opposite of what it boasts...it is another educational
institution that expects the students to learn they way it teaches instead of
teaching the way that individual child learns...which is a rip off for the
amount of fees parents pay.
—Submitted by a parent

Posted July 8, 2010
This can be a great school for your child or it can be a ridiculous experience.
I would advise you to learn the philosophy behind how and what they teach.Some
of the teachers are so wonderful and wise. If you had the experience we had it
is the result of poor teacher communication,poor administrative communication
and poor understanding of children. The teachers inability to correct or
understand my child in the most basic day to day classroom experience ensured
failure. Ignorance caused judgment by under qualified people which negatively
effected the daily life of my child sitting in the classroom. By placing my
child in more experienced school he has found so much confidence about how he
learns and the questions...oh the many questions he has about the world around
him!Many schools offer wonderful opportunities for our children, have fun
exploring!
—Submitted by a parent